Reviews for CD A Portland Selection: Contra Dance Music in the Pacific Northwest
Bill Spence (Andy’s Front Hall, Spring 2001)
Sue and Clyde published a book “The Portland Collection” in 1997. It’s a tunebook of favorite tunes of dance bands in the Portland, Oregon area and they decided it needed a CD to bring the tunes off the printed page and into the ear where they belong.
The tune selection is a cross-section of fast tunes, slow tunes. old tunes, and new tunes of every type from jigs and reels to hoedowns and a waltz. George Penk is a fiddler with a wonderful bounce in this playing that obviously comes from years of propelling dancers down the center with style. Sue’s piano is creative without getting in the way, and Clyde Curley adds mandolin and banjo in perfect sync with it all. Here and there you’ll hear Creighton Lindsay on guitar and dumbek.
This is simply a very listenable and eclectic group of 36 tunes that stands alone as a listening album. More important, perhaps, is its function as a companion piece to “The Portland Collection” book, enabling learning musicians to hear what this wonderful bunch of tunes sounds like.
– Copyright 2001 Andy’s Front Hall. All Rights Reserved. Used by Permission.
Bob Buckingham (Fiddler Magazine, Summer 2001)
This CD is intended as a companion to “The Portland Collection”, a fine book of contra dance tunes that has sold over 5000 copies. George Penk is the fiddler and a fine one he is. Contra dance music tends to lean toward the Celtic side and George is in full control. When he tackles a southern piece like “Liza Jane” or “Sally Ann Johnson”, he is equally at home. He is joined by the musicians whose names appeared on the book. Clyde Curley plays mandolin as well as octave mandolin and 4-string banjo. He tastefully switches between playing the melody and counterpoint or a harmony line, adding a subtle complexity to each dance set. Susan Songer is a piano accompanist par excellence. Her pulsing chord work with its fluid syncopation is the groundwork upon which George and Clyde work.
The recording quality is top notch, as are the interesting arrangements. The medleys give us examples of how these tunes can be linked for a dance. Those who are book-bound should take note that these musicians have taken the music beyond the limits of the written page as all good folk musicians are apt to do. If you have been enjoying the book, it is time now to hear the tunes and the authors playing them.
– Copyright 2001 Fiddler Magazine. All Rights Reserved. Used by Permission.
Bobbi Shearn Nickles (Strings Magazine, August/September 2001)
This pleasing, straightforward recording is a companion to a book of more than 300 popular contra dance tunes played in the Pacific Northwest, called “The Portland Collection”, published in 1997. The newly issued CD includes a lovely selection of tunes reflecting French Canadian, Scottish, Cape Breton, Irish, New England, and Southern fiddle traditions.
Together, the CD and book make a superb reference for anyone interested in this repertoire. Along with 20 melodies played in North America for centuries are 16 new tunes composed in the last 30 years. The players are Clyde Curley (mandolin, banjo), Susan Songer (piano), George Penk (fiddle), and Creighton Lindsay (guitar, percussion).
– From Strings Magazine, August/September 2001, Number 97. © 2001 String Letter Publishing. All Rights Reserved. Used by Permission. For more information on Publication, contact String Letter Publishing, PO Box 767, San Anselmo, CA 94979; (415) 485-6946; fax (415) 485-0831; www.stringletter.com.
Bruce E. Baker (Dirty Linen, February/March, 2002)
Most folks interested in contra dance music or in fiddling in general have come to know “The Portland Collection”, a wonderful tune book published in 1997. Now the creators of that collection, Susan Songer and Clyde Curley, have come out with a CD featuring 36 of the tunes from that book.
Leading the way on most tunes is fiddler George Penk, who has the sort of precise rhythm and snap to his playing one expects from a good dance fiddler. Songer’s piano provides a strong rhythmic base for nearly all the tracks, leaving Clyde Curley to augment either melody on mandolin or four-string banjo, or rhythm on octave mandolin. The music is well played throughout, adapting the peculiarities of various traditions (Irish, Appalachian, Quebecois) to the clean, smooth style demanded by contra dancers.
As with the printed collection, this recording features a number of the most popular recently composed tunes that have found their way into the tradition. The notes on the tunes are extensive and interesting.
– Copyright 2002, Dirty Linen, www.dirtylinen.com. All Rights Reserved. Used by Permission.
Brian Peters (Living Tradition), April, 2002
I undertake this review out of enthusiasm rather than duty. When I was sent the excellent contradance tune book “The Portland Collection” for review in another magazine, I became so entranced by the CD that arrived with it, that I resolved to review it in its own right for LT. It’s a defiantly home-produced release, with no named label or catalogue number, and the three musicians – from Portland, Oregon – are so unassuming they don’t even have a band name.
What they have produced, though, is as good an example of unpretentious, beautifully -played dance music as you could ever wish to hear. Leading the line is George Penk, a terrific fiddler with precision, great rhythmic attack, and enviable sweetness in the upper register, standing comparison with far more celebrated players.
Contra dance musicians are notoriously eclectic, and the selection contains tunes from New England, Quebec, the Appalachians, Ireland and Scotland, together with recent compositions, but rather than approach them with some homogenised, catch-all technique, Penk handles each in its appropriate style, executing lovely triplets and rolls for the Irish pieces and driving ahead of the beat for the old-timey material.
The support is no less accomplished: Clyde Curley, on mandolin, mandola and tenor banjo, supplies a subtle mixture of chording, unison melody and delicate harmony lines, while Sue Songer’s piano invests the rhythm with irresistible lift, resisting the excessive syncopation that’s all too common these days. As an ensemble the three are very, very tight. The tunes themselves are great, too. Marcel Messervier’s “Hommage à Edmond Parizeau” is as joyous an opening track as I’ve heard in years, “Damon’s Winder” and “Two Wide Nickels” are fine old-timey fiddle workouts, “Shetland’s Millbrae” is kicked along by banjo and particularly crunchy fiddle, while “Father Kelly’s Reel” is slowed down to produce a fine air. Dammit, they even make “The Mason’s Apron” sound fresh and exciting. This CD has hardly been out of my player these past few months!
Contra is beginning to catch on in England these days, and some musicians here are already trying out tunes from “The Portland Collection” (which Songer and Curley produced). If you want an outstanding role model for playing this, or indeed any other, kind of dance music, go to www.theportlandcollection.com and they’ll tell you how to order a copy. Trust me on this one!